Wednesday, July 02, 2008

Solved? Yeah?

The Indy today has one of those articles that pop up from time to time claiming to have solved the mystery of why Strads are the best.

Leaving aside the claims of Mr Guarneri del Gesu, one of the most gorgeous violin sounds I've encountered recently came from Christian Tetzlaff, whose tone in the Brahms concerto brought tears to the eyes simply by existing. Strad schmad, he plays a modern violin made by Peter Greiner in Germany.

It ain't what you've got, etc etc. Views, folks?

3 comments:

JW said...

Absolutely correct. Absolutely.

S.Llewellyn said...

Sam Zygmuntowicz in New York don't make chopped liver, neither!

Chip said...

I was at the East Neuk Festival this weekend and heard a Strad for the first time. While the violinist played beautifully, I don't know that I could discern anything overwhelming that I could attribute to the instrument.

The piano at the performance was a Steinway and while it too has a reputation, I found the ring out to be a bit dull. So, reputation isn't everything.