You know how to make a critic feel
really, seriously bad? Write to her the moment her review is published and tell
her you did that entire performance with an infection in your finger that had
made it swell up so much that you couldn’t fit it between the notes. A couple
of weeks ago I went to review Hershey Felder’s one-man show Our Great Tchaikovsky at the Other
Palace Theatre…and about 10 minutes after I published the write-up, there
pinged in a message from the man himself... Contrite, I went to see him last
Friday to hear about how he creates his composer-focused performances – and
about what he was going through on press night.
Silver birch: Felder as Tchaikovsky |
We’re in Tchaikovsky’s house in Klin. The
stage set that evokes it, anyway. Felder takes the piano stool and talks to me almost the same way that he performs, expressing himself on the piano as much as in words. He is soft-spoken when not acting,
but tenacious and determined as anyone must be when creating theatre pieces in
which he both acts and plays the piano – in the Tchaikovsky one, almost
continuously for an hour and 40 minutes – and performing them eight times a week.
“I arrived on the Sunday, and someone’s
luggage got caught on this finger, ripped the nail in half and dug all the way
into my finger,” Felder explains. “So I didn’t play for two days, but when I
started that week of performances, because I put pressure on it, it got worse
and started to swell. Tchaikovsky is awkward as it is, but I was in so much
pain – every time I was between two black notes I couldn’t fit.”
Bandages didn’t help much, ice made it
worse and Felder tried changing his technique and his fingering in order to
accommodate the problem: “The pain was massive and I had to play with flat
fingers rather than my usual technique.” Flat fingers worked for Horowitz, he
adds, but his own experience was slightly less happy. Then, 15 minutes before the
start on press night, “the whole thing broke open and there was blood all over
the keys.” It seems nothing short of miraculous that he was able to go ahead
with that performance all.
Felder grew up in Canada in a family in
which both sides were Holocaust survivors – his background mingles Russian,
Polish and Hungarian strands. “My Hungarian grandmother survived because she
was standing in line for a train when a little boy came up to her and told her
to play dead next time she saw a pile of bodies,” he recounts. Her family,
having survived the war, then escaped at the time of the Revolution in 1956.
Felder, fascinated by golden-age pianists
such as Busoni and Moritz Rosenthal, studied at Juilliard with Jerome
Lowenthal (who had studied with Cortot, among others). He was set on the idea of a career
performing and composing, and made his debut in London playing Rhapsody in Blue
at the Queen Elizabeth Hall when he was 19. But then, delving into his family
history in Poland, he was exploring Chopin heritage too and came across a piano
that belonged to the composer. The insights it brought him into how Chopin
must have played, he says, set him thinking about how to create a performance
to explore the matter. “But everyone said: ‘Chopping? Who’s heard of Chopping? Nobody
will come! Do someone everyone’s heard of. Do Cole Porter...’”
He didn’t want to do Cole Porter. “But I
saw how the audience responded to the music when I played Rhapsody in Blue.
Next thing I know, I’m telling the story of Gershwin. I didn’t think there
would be a business in story-telling. But there is. There really is. Today
people come to me from all over the world for help in creating similar shows.”
Among them was Mona Golabek, whose memoir The
Pianist of Willesden Lane was a smash hit here in London and has now been
optioned for a film.
Defying the nay-sayers, Felder pressed ahead
with more composer productions. His Bernstein show brought him a new friendship
with an unexpected new admirer, the great pianist Byron Janis (who is now 89).
He did do Chopin – and people did go. Ditto Beethoven, Liszt and Irving Berlin. The Liszt production, devised for the composer's bicentenary a few years back, focused on his support for Wagner, asking the crucial question, according to Felder, "If you know someone is going to turn out bad, do you support him anyway?" - a philosophical argument that set some audiences raging, but pushed the concept behind the show onto a new and vital level.
We nearly got his Irving Berlin in London this time, but four weeks before opening night, Felder says, he was so disillusioned with developments in Trump’s America that he switched to do his recently premiered Tchaikovsky instead. “I felt I couldn’t come to London and sing ‘God Bless America’ after they pardoned Arpaio,” he declares.
We nearly got his Irving Berlin in London this time, but four weeks before opening night, Felder says, he was so disillusioned with developments in Trump’s America that he switched to do his recently premiered Tchaikovsky instead. “I felt I couldn’t come to London and sing ‘God Bless America’ after they pardoned Arpaio,” he declares.
Our Great Tchaikovsky doesn’t shirk
difficult politics. “It’s ostensibly about Tchaikovsky,” Felder says, “but
actually it’s about propaganda, about erasing who Tchaikovsky was, what Russia
is doing now and how this threatens Americans in various communities on a daily
basis. It scares the hell out of me.” But in the panorama of Tchaikovsky’s
life, the story is relevant without effort, lavishly complemented by digital
animations that project across the setting of Klin images of animals grazing in
birch forests, images that transform from mountains to dancers to swans, and New
York in the snow (for The Nutcracker, dreamed up there when Tchaikovsky visited
to open Carnegie Hall). “The show evokes an era,” says Felder, “and that era is
Russia in the late 19th century.”
Rest assured that Felder is one heck of a terrific pianist, with sensitive and colourful touch, and flair to spare. Yet if you’re
battling an infected finger plus a difficult acoustic (the Other Palace
Theatre is extremely dry), what to do? A true pro presses on, and Felder is as
total a pro as you would find anywhere on the globe. There’s no business like showbusiness, as
someone once said, and for a one-man show there’s no understudy, no backup, no
safety net. Now that he’s better, I might make a return visit.